Lisa Mailhot | April 23, 2024
Buyers
The housing crisis in California has been a persistent issue, with a shortage of affordable and accessible housing options plaguing many communities. To address this challenge, the state has implemented a unique provision known as the "builder's remedy." This law, which has been on the books since 1990, is gaining traction and stirring up a heated debate between housing developers and local municipalities.
The builder's remedy allows developers to bypass local zoning rules in cities and counties that lack a state-certified housing plan, provided that a fifth of the units are reserved for low-income families and the project complies with environmental laws. With dozens of municipalities failing to meet their housing plan deadlines, a golden opportunity has emerged for developers to propose projects that would otherwise be rejected due to zoning restrictions.
However, this opportunity has not come without controversy. Cities and their lobbyists argue that the law is unclear, leading to disagreements over when the builder's remedy is triggered and what it entails. Some cities have resisted these applications, claiming that their housing plans were in "substantial compliance" before receiving state certification. At the same time, developers contend that compliance is achieved only after the state's formal approval.
Recent court rulings in Los Angeles County have shed light on this legal tug-of-war. In two cases, judges sided with developers, ruling that cities cannot "self-certify" or "backdate" their housing plan compliance to circumvent the builder's remedy. Additionally, one judge held that a city's refusal to process a builder's remedy application constitutes a "disapproval," potentially entitling developers to reimbursement for legal expenses.
These rulings, while not binding statewide, have emboldened developers and could impact ongoing cases in cities like Orange and Beverly Hills, where builders have faced denials or roadblocks. Notably, the city of La Habra has accepted a builder's remedy application from Lennar for a 530-home development on the Westridge golf course, albeit with the requirement for a costly environmental review.
As the battle rages on, two proposed bills in Sacramento aim to clarify and potentially rein in the builder's remedy. One bill seeks to codify the rule that city plans are not complete until the state housing department certifies them. At the same time, the other proposes limits on where and how much developers can build under the provision.
Despite the ongoing legal and legislative debates, one thing is clear: the builder's remedy has the potential to reshape housing development in California, providing developers with a powerful tool to circumvent local zoning restrictions and potentially alleviate the state's housing shortage.
If you're considering a move in Orange County, let's connect. As an experienced realtor, I can guide you through the complexities of the local housing market and ensure a smooth transition to your dream home, navigating the evolving landscape shaped by the "builder's remedy" and other housing laws.
Discover the 15 U.S. cities leading in quality of life for 2024–25, as ranked by U.S. News & World Report. From affordability challenges to cultural gems and natural b… Read more
Women are redefining the luxury real estate market, emerging as powerful decision-makers in high-end home buying and selling. Discover how this trend is transforming t… Read more
Protect your investment! Learn how to identify red flags in real estate scams, from wire fraud to fake listings. Safeguard your hard-earned money with these expert tip… Read more
Discover the trends that froze the real estate market in December, as homes lingered on the market and inventory plunged. What does this mean for buyers and sellers he… Read more
California's new insurance regulation requires coverage in wildfire-prone areas but may result in significant cost increases for homeowners. Learn how this impacts hom… Read more
As real estate braces for 2025, antitrust litigation remains a key battleground. Learn about the appeals, buyer-side lawsuits, policy shifts, and DOJ scrutiny reshapin… Read more
Quitclaim deeds are a quick and efficient way to transfer property between family members or spouses without a sale. Learn what a quitclaim deed is, how to create one,… Read more
In November, existing-home sales reached a three-year high with a 6.1% annual increase, led by significant growth across three major U.S. regions. This blog explores t… Read more
Explore the challenges and solutions facing homeowners in areas known as "insurance deserts" where escalating premiums and climate risks make obtaining affordable cove… Read more
Let's find a time that suits you best to chat about your goals, show you how we work, and figure out how we can help you the most