December 2025 Housing Market Shows Historic Slowdown as Buyer Caution Intensifies

Disclaimer: This blog is for informational purposes only and may reference third-party sources, including quotes or data used verbatim with proper credit. All efforts are made to ensure originality and avoid plagiarism. Readers should verify details independently and consult a licensed professional before making real estate decisions.

The housing market closed 2025 with a significant slowdown that has implications for both buyers and sellers heading into the new year. December's data reveals a market in transition, with pending home sales reaching their second-lowest level on record. For those navigating the Orange County real estate landscape, understanding these national trends provides crucial context for making informed decisions in the months ahead.

Pending Sales Drop to Near-Record Lows

December witnessed a substantial decline in housing activity across the nation. Pending home sales fell 5.9% from November to December on a seasonally adjusted basis, representing the largest monthly decrease since September 2022. This brought pending sales to their lowest point since April 2020, when the pandemic initially disrupted the housing market.

The year-over-year comparison tells a similarly cautious story. Pending sales declined 7.4% compared to December 2024, signaling that buyer hesitation has persisted throughout the year. These figures reflect a marketplace where prospective buyers are taking their time, carefully weighing their options before committing to what remains one of life's most significant financial decisions.

Economic Uncertainty Keeps Buyers on the Sidelines

Multiple factors are contributing to the current buyer reluctance. Housing affordability remains a primary concern, with mortgage rates still hovering above 6% despite recent declines from higher levels. While rates briefly dipped below this threshold following a federal mortgage bond purchase announcement, they remain more than double the historic lows experienced during the pandemic years.

Home prices continue their upward trajectory as well. The median sale price reached $428,742 in December, marking the highest December level ever recorded. Although the 0.5% annual increase represents the slowest growth rate since June 2023, it still means prices are climbing rather than falling. For many buyers, this combination of elevated rates and rising prices creates an affordability challenge that's difficult to overcome.

Beyond housing-specific factors, broader economic conditions are influencing buyer behavior. Concerns about employment stability and general economic uncertainty have made potential buyers more cautious about taking on significant debt. Real estate professionals across the country report that buyers are becoming increasingly selective, unwilling to compromise on their must-haves even in a market with more choices than in recent years.

Homes Spend More Time on Market

The pace of the housing market has noticeably decelerated. Properties going under contract in December spent a median of 60 days on the market, marking the slowest December pace in ten years. This represents a six-day increase from the previous year, indicating that the rapid turnover characteristic of recent years has given way to a more measured tempo.

Market participants are also experiencing higher rates of contract cancellations. Approximately 40,000 home purchases fell through in December, equal to 16.3% of homes that went under contract during the month. This represents the highest December cancellation rate in available records dating back to 2017, suggesting that even buyers who've made initial commitments are reconsidering their decisions.

New Listings Hit Two-Year Low

Sellers are pulling back alongside buyers. New listings of homes for sale decreased 1.4% month-over-month in December to reach the lowest seasonally adjusted level since January 2024. Year-over-year, new listings fell 4.9%, indicating that fewer homeowners are choosing to put their properties on the market.

Active inventory also declined, dropping 1.1% from November in the largest seasonally adjusted monthly decrease since June 2023. Despite this monthly decline, active listings remained 3.9% higher than the previous year, providing buyers with somewhat more options than they had in late 2024.

The seller retreat isn't surprising given the challenging conditions. Many potential sellers are themselves prospective buyers who face the same affordability hurdles when considering their next home. Additionally, sellers who purchased in recent years may find themselves in difficult equity positions after accounting for transaction costs and commissions.

Negotiating Power Shifts to Buyers

Current market conditions favor buyers in ways not seen in several years. Sellers are increasingly offering concessions and price reductions to attract offers. The typical home that sold in December went for 1.8% below its final asking price, representing the largest December discount since 2022.

Only 22% of homes sold for more than their final list price, the lowest December percentage since 2019. This marks a dramatic shift from the competitive bidding environments of 2021 and 2022, when sellers regularly received multiple over-asking offers. Today's sellers must be more strategic about pricing and presentation to achieve their goals.

Real estate agents are advising sellers to ensure their homes are well-maintained and to consider providing pre-inspections to build buyer confidence. Properties that show well and are priced appropriately for current conditions are still finding buyers, but sellers must adjust expectations from the frenzied markets of recent years.

Regional Variations in Market Performance

While national trends show weakness, some metropolitan areas are performing better than others. Among major markets, West Palm Beach, Florida saw pending sales increase 11.7% year-over-year, while Riverside and Anaheim, California experienced gains of 6.7% and 5% respectively.

Conversely, some markets faced steeper declines. San Jose, California experienced the sharpest drop with pending sales down 34.6% from the previous year. San Francisco and Minneapolis also saw significant decreases of 18.7% and 18.4% respectively.

Price trends varied considerably across regions as well. Detroit led price appreciation with an 8.9% year-over-year increase, while Dallas experienced the largest decline at negative 7.6%. These regional differences underscore the importance of understanding local market dynamics rather than relying solely on national statistics.

Orange County Market Outlook

While these national and regional trends provide important context, Orange County maintains its own unique market characteristics. The region's strong employment base, desirable climate, and quality of life continue to attract buyers even in challenging economic environments. However, the same affordability pressures affecting buyers nationwide are certainly present in our local market.

The current environment actually presents opportunities for well-prepared buyers and sellers. Buyers have more negotiating leverage and time to make considered decisions without the pressure of immediate competition. Sellers who price appropriately and present their homes well can still achieve successful sales, particularly if they're willing to work constructively with buyers on terms.

Bottomline

The December 2025 housing data reflects a market in transition, moving from the frenzy of recent years toward a more balanced dynamic between buyers and sellers. While challenges exist on both sides of transactions, opportunities remain for those who approach the market with realistic expectations and solid guidance.

If you're considering making a move in Orange County, whether buying your first home, upgrading to accommodate a growing family, or downsizing for the next chapter of life, now is an excellent time to explore your options. The current market conditions create space for thoughtful decision-making without the rushed timelines that characterized recent years. At Whitestone Real Estate, I specialize in helping clients navigate exactly these types of market transitions, ensuring you have the local expertise and strategic support needed to achieve your real estate goals. Let's connect to discuss how current conditions align with your specific situation and create a personalized plan for your success.

Reference: Katz, L. (2026, January 15). Pending home sales drop to lowest level on record aside from start of pandemic. Redfin News.