2025 and Beyond: Navigating the Turbulent Waters of Real Estate Antitrust Litigation

Lisa Mailhot  |  January 1, 2025

Buyers

2025 and Beyond: Navigating the Turbulent Waters of Real Estate Antitrust Litigation

 

The real estate industry is far from closing the chapter on antitrust litigation. While settlements like those in the Sitzer/Burnett and Moehrl cases aim to resolve claims related to commission rules, 2025 promises continued appeals, buyer-side lawsuits, policy reviews, and potential Department of Justice (DOJ) intervention. This year’s developments will define how brokers, agents, and consumers adapt to a changing market.

Appeals: The Fight Continues

Despite final court approvals, appeals against the National Association of Realtors’ (NAR) settlement persist. James Dwiggins, CEO of NextHome, expressed confidence that “the sell-side litigation is done,” but higher courts will ultimately decide the fate of these settlements. As Stephen Brobeck of the Consumer Federation of America noted, “Most of these challenges will be unsuccessful or achieve only marginal results.”

Buyer-Side Litigation: What It Means

Even as seller-side settlements weaken, the industry faces ongoing buyer-side commission lawsuits, such as Batton, Lutz, and Davis. These cases allege that NAR rules inflated buyer transaction costs. However, the settlements significantly reduce the potential class size for these lawsuits, as buyers who were also sellers are no longer eligible participants. Dwiggins noted:

“Now those cases are literally only first-time homebuyers.”

Policy Shifts and Industry Risks

The NAR settlement brought significant changes, such as eliminating mandatory offers of compensation to buyer agents through MLSs. These changes aim to enhance transparency and competition, but their practical application remains uncertain. As Kendall Bonner of eXp Realty pointed out, “The messy middle is a likely consequence,” with untrained agents risking further litigation due to misinterpretation of new rules.

Understanding the "No-Commingling Rule"

This optional NAR policy allows MLSs to prohibit brokerages from displaying MLS listings alongside non-MLS listings. While intended to protect data integrity, the rule is under scrutiny for its potential antitrust implications, especially as the DOJ continues its investigation.

The DOJ’s Watchful Eye

The DOJ has reopened investigations into several NAR policies, including the Clear Cooperation Policy and the no-commingling rule. The agency’s scrutiny signals a potential lawsuit in 2025. While shifts in political administration could influence the DOJ’s approach, its commitment to fostering a competitive industry remains steadfast.

What’s Next for Real Estate?

Experts agree that adapting to policy changes offers both challenges and opportunities. A proactive approach to innovation and education is essential for minimizing risks and embracing a more consumer-centric model. As Bonner aptly stated:

“It’s time to remove barriers to change, when change is needed.”

Bottomline

The landscape of real estate is evolving rapidly, with 2025 poised to be a year of transformation. From ongoing appeals to DOJ oversight, the industry faces unprecedented challenges. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing, understanding these changes is vital. Let’s connect to explore how we can navigate this new era together.

 

 

Reference: McPherson, M., & Brambila, A. V. (2024, December 24). It’s not over yet: Where real estate antitrust litigation is going in 2025. Inman.

RECENT BLOG POSTS

Why Tiny Home Prices Are About to Surge—And What It Means for Orange County Buyers

New tariffs on Chinese imports are already causing sharp increases in tiny home and ADU prices. In high-cost regions like Orange County, this could significantly impac… Read more

The Hidden Risk in Buyer Love Letters (And How to Avoid It)

Buyer love letters might tug at heartstrings, but they can also tread dangerous legal ground. Learn the top three ways these letters could violate Fair Housing laws — … Read more

When Repairs Go Wrong: Can You Legally Withhold Rent in California?

Renters have more power than they think when it comes to repair issues in California. This blog breaks down your rights as a tenant, including when and how you can leg… Read more

Midwest Home Prices Surge Fastest in the Nation

The Midwest is on fire—and we’re not talking weather. Home prices in cities like Milwaukee and Detroit are soaring due to tight inventory and high demand. This blog di… Read more

Why Buyers Need Over $52K More Than Renters—and the Gap’s Growing

The income gap between renting and owning a home has surged to over $52,000 in 2025. While rent increases have slowed, home prices and mortgage rates remain high, maki… Read more

Gas Prices Drop, Inflation Slows—Here’s What That Could Mean for Your Mortgage

Inflation cooled in March thanks to falling gas prices, providing a temporary sigh of relief for mortgage markets. While rates aren't dropping just yet, lower pressure… Read more

Why Homebuyers Are Turning to Stocks for Their Down Payments

A new Redfin survey reveals that 1 in 5 homebuyers plan to sell stocks to fund their down payment. As market volatility shakes confidence, homeowners and renters alike… Read more

Why Strong Jobs Aren’t Sparking a Housing Comeback

Despite a strong March jobs report, new tariffs and rising economic uncertainty are casting a shadow over the housing market. Here’s how these national trends could pl… Read more

New MLS Rules Let Sellers Choose How to List

The National Association of Realtors® just introduced a new companion to its Clear Cooperation Policy: Multiple Listing Options for Sellers. This update offers sellers… Read more

We are excited to assist you in finding your perfect home

Let's find a time that suits you best to chat about your goals, show you how we work, and figure out how we can help you the most