Navigating the Rising Tide: Protecting Your Home in Insurance Deserts

Lisa Mailhot  |  December 20, 2024

Buyers

Navigating the Rising Tide: Protecting Your Home in Insurance Deserts

 

In recent times, the cost of homeowners insurance has surged significantly, with some Americans seeing their premiums double, and for many, policies have become unaffordable due to heightened climate risks. This phenomenon has led to the creation of "insurance deserts" - areas where it's either too expensive or impossible to obtain insurance because of environmental threats. According to a recent report from Realtor.com’s economics team, nearly half of all U.S. homes are at risk of severe damage from natural disasters, encompassing almost $22 trillion in residential real estate.

The Market Reaction

The response from the insurance industry has been notably harsh, with premiums soaring and some insurers withdrawing from high-risk markets entirely. For instance, Florida has seen more than 30 home insurance companies exit the state, as noted by Bankrate, leading to a less competitive and more costly market. Angela Hudgens, a Florida homeowner, highlighted the relentless increase in premiums, expressing concern over the affordability of continuous coverage.

Legislative Efforts for Reform

Efforts to stabilize the insurance market are underway, spearheaded by figures such as former Florida Sen. Jeff Brandes. He founded The Florida Policy Project to encourage the adoption of best practices in insurance and housing sectors to help curb the spiraling costs and keep the insurance market viable for more Americans.

Expanding Beyond Florida

The issue of rising insurance premiums is not confined to Florida. States like California, Louisiana, and even Colorado are witnessing similar trends. High-risk areas across the country are facing significant insurance availability challenges, pushing homeowners to either forego insurance or seek alternative measures.

 

What Homeowners Can Do

For those in high-risk areas, there are still actions to be taken to mitigate risks and secure insurance. Consulting with independent insurance agents can provide access to a broader range of options tailored to specific needs. Additionally, making homes more resilient to natural disasters, such as installing fire-resistant roofing in wildfire-prone areas, can help in making properties insurable.

Insurance Options for Challenging Markets

In states with severe insurance deficits, looking into insurers of last resort, such as the FAIR Plan, is advisable. These plans are designed to offer coverage where the private market fails to do so, ensuring that homeowners can still protect their assets against unforeseen events.

Bottomline

As the landscape of homeowners insurance continues to evolve in response to climate change and market dynamics, being informed and proactive is key. If you're considering moving to or are already living in an area with high insurance risks like Orange County, connecting with an experienced professional can provide you with the insights and assistance you need. Let's connect and find the best solutions for your housing needs.

 

 

Reference: "Millions of Americans Live in ‘Insurance Deserts’—but There Are Ways To Protect Your Home" by Julie Taylor, Realtor.com, December 19, 2024.

RECENT BLOG POSTS

Builders Bet on Fed Rate Cuts To Revive the Housing Market

Homebuilder sentiment remains low as reliance on price cuts grows, but optimism is building with the potential for a Federal Reserve rate cut. Mortgage rates have alre… Read more

Mortgage Momentum: Applications Surge as Rates Drop to 11-Month Low

Mortgage applications just hit a three-year high as rates dip to their lowest since October 2024. Learn why this could be a window of opportunity for both buyers and s… Read more

Rents Surge Across the U.S. as Apartment Construction Slows

The U.S. rental market is heating up again, with asking rents climbing at the fastest pace since 2022. Limited new apartment construction and strong demand are fueling… Read more

Homeownership Slips While Rentership Surges in 2025

A new Redfin analysis shows the U.S. homeowner population ticked down 0.1% year over year in Q2 2025 while renter households jumped 2.6%. Prices remain high, mortgage … Read more

Orange County Buyers Gain Momentum as Pending Home Sales Rise

Pending home sales are climbing for the second month in a row, while mortgage rates have dropped to their lowest level in 10 months. More affordable listings are hitti… Read more

Why New Homes Are Losing Ground to Resales

New-home sales slowed in July 2025 as affordability challenges weighed heavily on buyers, despite builder incentives and discounts. With prices dropping below existing… Read more

Job Security Anxiety Puts the Brakes on Homebuying

Nearly half of U.S. workers are reconsidering big financial moves like purchasing a home because of concerns over job stability, according to a new Redfin survey. Whil… Read more

July 2025 Housing Report Shows Growth in Southern Home Construction While Other Regions Experience Declines

July 2025 housing starts data shows single-family construction climbing in the South while slowing in other parts of the country. For Orange County buyers and sellers,… Read more

Permits for Apartments Drop 23% Will Rents Start Climbing?

Apartment-building permits slowed across the U.S. this past year, signaling tighter future rental supply even as demand firms back up. Here’s what the national trend—a… Read more

We are excited to assist you in finding your perfect home

Let's find a time that suits you best to chat about your goals, show you how we work, and figure out how we can help you the most