Real Estate in Flux: What NAR’s Settlement and the Batton II Lawsuit Mean for the Industry

Lisa Mailhot  |  November 29, 2024

Buyers

Real Estate in Flux: What NAR’s Settlement and the Batton II Lawsuit Mean for the Industry

 

The real estate industry continues to face seismic changes as lawsuits and settlements reshape commission structures and agent practices. While the National Association of Realtors (NAR) achieved a major settlement approval recently, new developments, such as the Batton II lawsuit, signal that legal challenges are far from over.

 A Temporary Resolution

On Tuesday, Judge Stephen R. Bough granted final approval to a landmark settlement involving NAR, HomeServices of America, and other major real estate players. This settlement resolved antitrust claims brought by home sellers in cases like Sitzer | Burnett and Moehrl, which alleged that these entities conspired to inflate broker commissions.

While significant, the settlement leaves lingering questions. It primarily addresses claims by home sellers, leaving homebuyers who weren’t sellers with unresolved grievances. The Department of Justice (DOJ) has also signaled that its investigation into NAR’s policies remains active, emphasizing that this settlement is not a definitive end to industry litigation.

The Growing Scope of Batton II

On the same day as the NAR settlement, a new filing in the Batton II case expanded its scope. This Illinois-based class action lawsuit accuses Compass, eXp, Redfin, Weichert, and United Real Estate of engaging in anticompetitive practices that inflate buyer costs while providing subpar services.

Twenty-two new homebuyer plaintiffs from 19 states joined the suit, bringing the total to 32 plaintiffs. The plaintiffs argue that the defendants’ practices misrepresent broker services as “free,” causing homebuyers to overpay in commissions and property prices.

The Legal Fallout for Real Estate Firms

Real estate companies like eXp and Weichert, not covered by the NAR settlement, face additional legal hurdles. eXp recently reached a $34 million settlement in the Hooper case but hit a roadblock when Judge Bough raised concerns over the terms, citing the need for further discovery.

Meanwhile, Baird & Warner, an Illinois-based brokerage, settled in the Gibson case after transacting $6.27 billion in 2022. The specifics of this settlement remain undisclosed, but it adds another layer to the ongoing legal complexities for firms outside the NAR umbrella.

The DOJ’s Ongoing Role

The DOJ remains a critical player, challenging key provisions of the NAR settlement. Specifically, it opposes requiring buyers to sign representation agreements before touring homes, arguing that such practices could spark further antitrust concerns.

Their active investigation underscores that the industry’s legal battles are far from resolved, even with high-profile settlements. Agents, buyers, and sellers alike must navigate an evolving landscape influenced by these lawsuits and policy debates.

Bottomline

The real estate industry is at a crossroads, with ongoing lawsuits and settlements poised to reshape how agents, buyers, and sellers interact. Understanding these changes is essential for anyone involved in the market. If you’re planning your next move to Orange County or beyond, let’s connect to explore your options and navigate the shifting landscape together.

 

 

Reference: Anderson, T. (2024, November 27). As NAR Settlement Wins Approval, Batton II Commission Lawsuit Grows. Inman. Retrieved from https://www.inman.com

RECENT BLOG POSTS

Real Estate Commissions: The Shake-Up of 2025

Homebuyer and seller commission negotiations are heating up after new rules took effect in August. Discover how these changes are impacting average commission rates, n… Read more

State Farm's 22% Rate Hike Shocks California Homeowners

In the aftermath of devastating LA wildfires, State Farm has requested a 22% insurance rate hike in California. Discover how this could impact homeowners, why wildfire… Read more

Unlock Higher Returns with Smarter Rental Strategies in 2025

With rental market growth set to hit $5.35 trillion globally by 2025, investors can boost returns by diversifying portfolios, leveraging tech, and adopting proactive m… Read more

Boomers on Lockdown: The $84 Trillion Wealth Transfer on Hold

Baby boomers are holding tight to their real estate and assets, delaying the long-anticipated "Great Wealth Transfer." Learn how this affects millennials, Gen Xers, an… Read more

New-Home Sales Surge Despite High Rates – Impact on Buyers & Seller

New-home sales defied expectations in December, rising 3.6% despite mortgage rates hovering around 7%. With builders offering incentives and inventory rising, now migh… Read more

Tiny Living, Big Impact – How Micro-Units Are Reshaping the Rental Market

As cities struggle with rising rents, micro-units are emerging as a practical solution for affordability and quality living. These compact, well-designed apartments of… Read more

When Weather Drives Up the Cost of Homeownership

Extreme weather is driving up home insurance premiums, with costs soaring 33% in recent years. Discover how climate risks are reshaping real estate markets, from risin… Read more

Own a Slice of Michael Jordan’s Legendary Mansion Starting at $1M

Michael Jordan's iconic Highland Park mansion, Champions Point, is now available for co-ownership starting at $1M. This unique opportunity offers luxury amenities, com… Read more

Wildfires Threaten $40 Billion in Los Angeles Real Estate

L.A. wildfires in January 2025 have put over $40 billion in real estate at risk, highlighting housing shortages and displacement concerns. Discover how these events im… Read more

We are excited to assist you in finding your perfect home

Let's find a time that suits you best to chat about your goals, show you how we work, and figure out how we can help you the most